What’s Your Guitar Story?

Submit your true story. Inspire someone. Maybe even win a dream guitar.

In a world often overwhelmed by social media, AI, and divisive news, our community’s guitar stories will offer authenticity, connection, and a powerful reminder of what truly matters.

Stories submitted as of May 18th
3

Submission deadline: May 30th

Why Guitar Stories?

In the decade since starting Tony’s Acoustic Challenge, one thing stands out clearly—your heartfelt stories and the deep reasons behind why you play guitar.

We want to share guitar stories that inspire new guitar players to keep going.

We’re looking for true, vivid stories from everyday people—focused on one powerful experience. They should recount impactful experiences and do so in ways that move and inspire us. They can be a moment of triumph, a sweet encounter, or a hilarious misadventure.

A good story inspires us to reflect inward. It helps us to connect with others and with ourselves. It expands our hearts and lets us carry lessons and inspiration from others’ lives.

A good story gives us goosebumps. It makes us laugh, cry, or hold our breath in anticipation. The author’s account draws us into the narrative and evokes real emotion.

In a world often overwhelmed by social media, AI, and divisive news, our community’s guitar stories will offer authenticity, connection, and a powerful reminder of what truly matters.

If your story inspires even one person to pick up the guitar or persevere, it’s worth sharing.

Win a Taylor Guitar

One randomly selected, approved story submission will win this 50th Anniversary Taylor 314ce valued at $2799.00 – provided by Eddie’s Guitars.

To enter the giveaway, submit a story that follows the guidelines by Friday, May 30th; we’ll announce the winner via email and on this page the following week.

No purchase, TAC membership, or donation necessary. But if you’d like to support Guitars for Vets, you’ll find an option to do that when you submit.

How Will My Story Be Used?

We’ll share the best stories on our website, email list, and YouTube channel to inspire guitar enthusiasts around the world. Ultimately, we dream of publishing a “Guitar Stories” book series.

Story Topic Ideas

Need inspiration? Here are some ideas to help you recall a guitar-related story you’d like to share. These are just suggestions; feel free to submit any story that resonates deeply with you.

Change Your Habits & Attitudes

  • Deciding to commit to learning guitar
  • Overcoming procrastination to practice regularly
  • How playing guitar transformed your daily routine
  • Breaking habits that hindered your guitar progress
  • Becoming disciplined or building new practice habits

Family Connections & Memories

  • A guitar passed down through generations
  • Bonding with family through music
  • Teaching your child or grandchild their first chords
  • Memories of playing music with loved ones
  • Musical traditions in your family

Overcoming Fears & Limiting Beliefs

  • Performing for an audience for the first time
  • How guitar helped you overcome anxiety or fear
  • Believing in your ability to learn and grow as a musician
  • Facing and overcoming self-doubt through guitar
  • A moment when guitar playing boosted your confidence

Joy, Grief, or Inspiration

  • How guitar brought joy during difficult times
  • Healing or coping with loss through music
  • Inspirational moments related to your guitar journey
  • Guitar moments that deeply moved or changed you
  • How guitar has inspired you or others around you

Submission Guidelines

We’re building a lasting collection of true guitar stories—personal, emotional, and crafted with care.

We’re looking for true, beautifully told stories—the kind that stir emotions, paint vivid pictures, and stay with you long after you finish reading.

Our standard is high.
We want stories that would fit inside a Chicken Soup for the Soul collection—only with guitars at the center.


✅ What We’re Looking For:

  • One true, personal story about how guitar changed, healed, or deepened your life.

  • First-person storytelling (tell it like you’re sitting across the table from someone you care about).

  • Structured storytelling with a clear beginning, middle, and end.

  • Vivid details and emotional moments (make us feel it, not just hear it).

  • Length: Around 600–1,200 carefully chosen words (tight and powerful).

  • Originality: Your story must be unpublished, and written in your own voice.

  • An accompanying photo: Your submission should include a photo of you smiling and holding your guitar. See example photos.

✍️ Important:

You don’t need fancy words. You need real ones.

The most powerful stories aren’t fancy.
They’re honest.
They bring us into a real moment of joy, loss, healing, or hope.

If you’re willing to put in the heart and thought to tell a true, meaningful story — even if it’s not “perfect” — we want to hear it.

(And if you need inspiration, we strongly encourage reading a few stories from Chicken Soup for the Soul before writing.)


❌ What Won’t Be Accepted:

  • A life timeline or general overview without a focused story.

  • Testimonials about Tony’s Acoustic Challenge.

  • Political, divisive, or controversial content.

  • Fiction, poetry, advice piece, or sermon 


🎸 Tips for a Compelling Story:

  • Start in the action: Grab us from the first line.

  • Use vivid imagery: Let us see and feel your experience.

  • Include a moment of change: Show us what you felt, learned, or overcame.

  • Focus on one powerful moment: Zoom in on a true experience that shaped you. One story, one heartbeat.

❌ Not This:

(General, surface-level, not an actual story)

“I got my first guitar when I was 18 and it was a red Fender. I played a little but then life got busy. After retiring, I picked it back up again and started practicing more. I found Tony’s lessons and now I’m having fun learning. Guitar has always been something I loved, and I’m glad I stuck with it. It brings me a lot of happiness.”

Why This Doesn’t Work:

  • No emotional center: We’re told facts, but we don’t feel anything.

  • No real story structure: It’s just a timeline of events without a clear beginning, middle, or end.

  • No vivid moment: Nothing specific happens that pulls us into the experience.

  • Too general and surface-level: We don’t get inside a meaningful moment or transformation.

  • Mentions TAC: (This isn’t a project to gather TAC testimonials.)

✅ This:

Harmony of Hope

by Tony Polecastro

“…your parents are ok, but something happened.”

My sister-in-law Jodie didn’t have much more information other than that my folks had gotten in a motorcycle accident and that my Mom and Dad were rushed to the closest hospital. I got the call while on my way to a gig with my long time musical partner Shelly. She was driving and only heard my shocked and deadpan one word answers while I was on the phone. Something wasn’t right, something was off.

My head was spinning and I locked up. I didn’t know what to do, I didn’t know what to think, I wasn’t even sure if what I had heard was real. Shelly kindly asked if we should turn around and cancel the gig… I just said no and we carried on and played the show, which I was physically at, but mentally I was miles away.

The next day, Whitney and I made plans, with the encouragement and support from her parents, to go back to Chicago and spend time with my folks. We packed up the car, pointed it towards Chicago, and arrived at my childhood home late in the evening after three days of driving. The house was eerily different and familiar all at the same time.

The house smelled the same, the pictures and art hung on the wall just as I had remembered, and the basement door’s glass still rattled the same way it did when I was trying to sneak out during my first years of high school.

Everything was exactly as it was the morning when my parents had left for their ride. Two empty coffee cups in the sink, some bills stamped and ready to go to the post office on the kitchen counter, that night’s dinner recipe out by the stove so Mom could start right in when they got back, but they never made it home that afternoon.

The following morning we left for the hospital and when we arrived there was a flood of every conceivable emotion. Seeing my folks laid up in hospital beds was jarring, they’re the strongest, most independent people I know, and seeing them so vulnerable broke my heart.

I always travel with my guitar, and at Whitney’s suggestion, I brought it to the hospital that day… she said it would mean a lot to my folks to hear me play and have a healthy distraction. My wife is always right, but I didn’t know just how right she would be…

As the four of us sat and caught up in between the frequent visits from nurses and doctors, my Dad asked if I was going to play that thing or just lug it around. My Dad taught me guitar, and we’d often sit and play songs whenever I would come back and visit, but it was very clear we wouldn’t be playing together today, or so I had thought.

I started playing and singing “Oh My Sweet Carolina” by Ryan Adams. I had just learned the song and given the situation, it felt like a nice mellow song to play. Nearing the end of the song I decided to tag the chorus again and what I heard filled my soul beyond comprehension… my Dad, always a keen listener, joined in and sang harmony with me.

Right there, from his clearly awkward and uncomfortable hospital bed, his leg in a full cast, monitors & machines buzzing in the background, he sang right along with me. Whitney and Mom experienced the same magic that I felt and heard.

It transcended music, it was healing, it was hope…

It didn’t matter if our harmony was “right.” The song itself was irrelevant. The way I played had nothing to do with it. It was about being together and having a sign that, despite the heaviness of the situation, things would be ok.

It was the purest form of expression, love, and connection. We stuck around Chicago for about a week visiting the hospital as often as the nurses and doctors would let us, and when we decided to head back home it was more than difficult. I felt the pull of wanting to stay and help, as well as, the sense of urgency to get back to life’s obligations Whitney and I had back in Montana.

The drive home felt longer than it usually does. The rest areas and gas stations seemed farther apart, the car moved slower than what the speedometer claimed. It was emotional purgatory The more I thought on that drive, the more I relished in the memory of my Dad and I singing together. That singular moment, that singular chorus repeat will be burned in my mind forever. Without question, Dad and I’s relationship deepened that day, but something else happened. I had always looked to my guitar as an escape of sorts. The busy-ness and stresses of life seemed to evaporate when I played guitar. It was a tool that, up until this point, I used to ignore the things that I simply didn’t want to deal with.

In that hospital room the guitar grew into a tool that I used to explore and express, rather than ignore, the feelings I previously ran from. It helped me sink into the hurt, the fear, the anxiety… the good and the bad. No longer did the guitar numb and drown out, now it was a confidant, a sounding board, and, in essence, it set me free to unload emotional baggage that I thought I would perpetually bear the burden of.

After what felt like a month of driving we arrived back home to our apartment. Walking up the stairs to our unit the sun felt warmer and a bit brighter, our smiles felt more sincere, and when we opened our door Whitney and I hugged longer than we normally did.

The next day Whitney and I would prepare for our “regular” life again. We would sit at our kitchen table and drink coffee. I knew I would be thinking about what my parents’ life would look like henceforth, and deep in my core I knew their coffee cups would be cleaned, I knew their bills would get mailed, and I knew that Mom would follow that recipe for dinner.

Deep down, I had unwavering conviction my family would get through this rough chapter and things would slowly ease into a new normal. It would no doubt be a tough transition and I was reassured I had a way to sort through my feelings as opposed to ignoring them.

Why This Works:

  • It drops the reader into a real moment of tension, instead of starting with background information. Here’s another example of this.

  • Emotional core: It centers on love, family, vulnerability, and healing through music.

  • Specific, vivid scene: We are pulled into a hospital room where something real and moving happens.

  • Strong structure: Clear beginning (the accident call), middle (visiting parents, playing music), and end (deepened family bond, personal growth).

  • Sensory details: We can see, hear, and feel the experience (glass rattling door, monitors buzzing, the awkward hospital bed).

  • Emotional transformation: Guitar isn’t just an object — it becomes a tool for expression, healing, and connection.

  • No TAC mention: It’s about the story and the deeper emotional meaning.

🎯 For Best Results

We recommend:

Write your story offline first.
Use a document editor (Google Docs, Word, or Notes App) so you can take your time, save your progress, and revise thoughtfully.

Revise at least once.
A powerful story often comes from a second look. Tighten it, deepen the emotion, and make sure it flows.

Paste only when you’re proud.
When your story feels true, meaningful, and complete—then paste it into the submission form.

Don’t forget the photo.
Attach a smiling photo of you with your guitar (see examples!) before hitting submit.

Every story that touches a heart strengthens our community.
Every word you write can become a bridge for someone else.

True stories, well told, change lives.
We can’t wait to read yours.

Submission deadline: May 30th

Questions or thoughts? Let’s hear them…

Responses

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. This will be a huge challenge for me but I’m ex tied to have something to work towards. I have homeschooled 8 kids so far and writing by far was/is not my strong suit. But I guess I will be put in the spotlight to actually do the work I ask of my kids. This is a season of learning to express myself I guess. Thanks for TAC

  2. I have resubmitted mine and hope it is more inline with the expected storyline. Will I be notified if/when it is submitted? Thanks!

  3. I am not ready for a story. I have made progress but I am still working on improving, I have had improvement. I will keep working. Thank you Toni, glad I found you

  4. Hey Tony. When I first heard about the writing challenge, I assumed I had no story to share but I do. After spending the better part of a morning typing while wiping away the tears, I got the story out and on paper. I’m thrilled and could stop right there but I would like to share it. Of course it is way over your limit so I’m double checking because yours was much longer than mine. Mine comes in at 3,000 some odd words. I need to cut it to under 1,200. Correct?

  5. Do we get an email confirmation after submitting the story? I tried to upload mine yesterday but I’m not sure it got through…

  6. I had a problem getting to 600 and started rambling but hope it works, If I randomly won a guitar I will donate to your Vet program, Thanks Tony.

    1. Thanks for submitting, John! No worries. Take your time, review our updated guidelines (we’ve added examples and tried to give more story tips) then feel free to submit a story if you think you have one that fits the requirements.

    2. Just an update here, John. Your story is great! Our editor was able to do a light edit to help with flow and to fit the ideal structure. And if anyone else is reading this wondering if their story is “good enough”. Just try your best to follow the guidelines, but know that we can help you shape your story even if you don’t feel like you’re a great writer. If you’re in doubt, just submit.

  7. I absolutely love this idea. It nearly brought tears to my eyes because this will definitely be therapeutic, as well as inspirational for so many.

    1. Great job on your story Tony, this is a fabulous idea and the Taylor is a sweet sweet carrot to dangle motivation. The hospital resonates with me personally and my own life journey. I hope you get an abundance of Soup submissions. There should be some good reads in the mix. I wonder if you’ll share all submissions or just a few select notables. Also maybe you could offer some runner-up stuff like TAC memberships or gear like capos or tuners or “stuff” to keep the carrot swinging. I’d like to write a story but don’t feel like I’m up for the challenge and I have a nice 30th anniversary Breedlove so I hope your winner is the most deserving but the most deserving may not be the best writer. Plus I have trouble following rules and counting words and stuff. Eddie’s looks like a cool place, maybe he will recoup the value from his charitable donation . ♡♡
      All n’ all this adds up pretty promising all around. Lovin’ life here at TAC.
      Life Member Rick sayin’ Great job Tony!! ♡♡